Guide
Klaviyo Audit
The Checklist
Auditing Klaviyo
Area by Area
Short answer
A useful Klaviyo audit checks six areas: data and integrations, deliverability, flows, campaigns and audiences, design, and reporting. It should end with a ranked list of fixes tied to business outcomes like first-to-second-order conversion and subscriber retention, not just a list of settings. Run one when email revenue slips, before switching agencies, or once a year.
When should you audit your Klaviyo account?
Most brands wait too long. These are the usual triggers:
Revenue from email has dropped or flattened while the rest of the business grew.
You’re about to change agencies or bring email in-house.
You rebranded, changed platforms or added subscriptions.
Nobody can explain what each flow does or when it was last changed.
It’s been a year since anyone looked properly.
1. Data and integrations
Everything else depends on this.
Shopify (or your store) integration is connected and syncing orders, products and customers.
Key events fire: Viewed Product, Added to Cart, Checkout Started, Placed Order, Fulfilled Order. (Viewed Product and Added to Cart need onsite tracking turned on.)
Subscription app data flows in (if you sell subscriptions): upcoming charge, skipped, cancelled, payment failed.
Reviews, loyalty and helpdesk tools are connected where you use them.
Sign-up forms record where each subscriber came from.
Consent for email and SMS is collected and stored correctly.
2. Deliverability
If emails don’t reach the inbox, nothing else in the audit matters.
A branded sending domain is set up with SPF, DKIM and DMARC.
Spam complaint rate stays below 0.1% and never reaches 0.3%, the limits in Google’s sender guidelines.
One-click unsubscribe and a visible unsubscribe link are present, as Google requires for anyone sending more than 5,000 messages a day to Gmail.
Unengaged profiles are suppressed or sent to less often, and a sunset flow exists.
Open and click trends by inbox provider are stable, with no sudden drops at one provider.
3. Flows
Check each flow for three things: does it exist, does it fire correctly, and is it built for the right customer?
Welcome / first purchase: split by whether the subscriber has already bought.
Browse, cart and checkout abandonment: each fires once, with sensible timing and no duplicates.
Post-purchase: helps customers use what they bought and leads to the next order. See the second-purchase guide.
Replenishment for consumables, timed to how long products actually last.
Subscription flows: upcoming charge reminders, skip/swap prompts, failed payment recovery and cancellation save.
Win-back for lapsed buyers.
Sunset for subscribers who stopped engaging.
Filters stop people getting conflicting messages (for example, a win-back email a day after they reordered).
Every flow is on-brand and uses current products.
4. Campaigns and audiences
This is where most lists get worn out.
A calendar exists at least a few weeks ahead.
Campaigns go to segments built on behavior (first-time buyers, repeat buyers, lapsed, VIP, subscribers), not the whole list every time.
Discounts aren’t the default reason to email, so customers aren’t trained to wait for a sale.
Email and SMS are planned together so people don’t get the same message twice in an hour.
Peak periods like Black Friday have a plan. See our BFCM playbook.
5. Design
In an audit, design problems usually point to how the emails are built, so check the setup, not just the look. If the emails clearly look dated, our email redesign guide covers what to do next.
Count the different headers, footers and product layouts in live flows and campaigns. More than a couple means templates are one-off copies.
Headers, footers and legal text come from shared blocks, so one change updates every email. See Klaviyo design systems.
Every live flow email has been opened recently, not just campaigns. Flows are where old logos, discontinued products and expired codes hide longest.
Headlines and key copy are live text with alt text on images, and emails hold up on a phone and in dark mode.
6. Reporting and testing
The last check is whether anyone can tell what’s working.
Someone reports on repeat purchase rate, time to second order, subscriber retention and customer lifetime value, not just opens and clicks.
Flow performance is reviewed regularly, by revenue per recipient.
There’s a testing plan, and results are written down and reused.
Attribution settings are understood, so nobody over- or under-credits email.
How do you turn findings into a plan?
An audit that ends in a long list helps nobody. Rank every finding by two things: how much revenue or retention it affects, and how hard it is to fix. Broken or missing high-traffic flows usually come first, then deliverability issues, then audiences, then design and testing. Give each fix an owner and a date.
Who should run your Klaviyo audit?
There are three realistic options:
Yourself, using this checklist, if you know Klaviyo well.
Your current agency, though it’s hard to audit your own work objectively.
An outside specialist or agency, for a fresh view. Many offer audits before a retainer; confirm the findings are yours to keep either way.
How Swayleo approaches this
We start every engagement with an audit like this one, because the fixes that matter are different for every brand. We pay most attention to the business picture: where first-time buyers drop off before a second order, where subscribers churn, and what your customer data says about who should hear what. The output is a ranked plan, not a settings list, and it becomes the start of our playbook for your brand. That holds whether you bring us in for design only or for the full retention program. See how we work.
Talk to Swayleo
Want the founders to look at this for your brand? If you’re a 7-figure Shopify or DTC brand, book a strategy call.
Shopify & DTC brands
Quick Answers
Frequently
Asked Questions
What should a Klaviyo audit include?
It should cover data and integrations, deliverability, flows, campaigns and audiences, design, and reporting, and end with a ranked list of fixes tied to business outcomes.
How often should I audit my Klaviyo account?
At least once a year, and whenever email revenue drops, you change agencies, rebrand or add subscriptions.
Can I audit Klaviyo myself?
Yes, if you know the platform well. A checklist covers the basics; an outside view helps spot issues you’re used to seeing.
What are the most common Klaviyo audit findings?
Common findings include missing or duplicate abandonment flows, welcome flows that treat customers and new subscribers the same, emailing the whole list too often, and reporting that tracks opens instead of repeat purchases.
Should my current agency audit its own work?
It can, but an outside audit is more objective, especially if you’re considering a switch.
Shopify & DTC brands