Guide
Switching Agencies
The Handover
Changing Agencies
Step by Step
Short answer
Switch email agencies when results have stalled for several months, nobody can explain the strategy, or the work no longer matches your brand. Switch safely by making sure you are the Owner of your Klaviyo account, writing down a baseline, getting an outside audit, and never pausing live flows until their replacements prove they perform at least as well.
What are the signs it’s time to switch?
No single bad month means much. Patterns do:
Results are flat or falling while the rest of the business grows, and the agency can’t explain why.
Reports show activity, not outcomes. Emails sent and open rates, but nothing on repeat purchases or customer value.
The work looks generic. Emails no longer match your brand, or the copy reads like it could be for anyone.
You’re managing them. You plan the calendar, chase approvals and catch errors.
Flows haven’t changed. The same automations have run untouched for a year.
Your account changed hands quietly. The strategist you signed with moved on, and nobody told you who replaced them.
No testing. Or tests run, but nobody uses the results.
One of these is a conversation. Three or more is usually a decision.
Should you fix the relationship first?
Sometimes. Before switching, tell your current agency exactly what’s wrong and what would change your mind, with a date. Good agencies respond. If they can’t or won’t, you’ve lost a few weeks, not a quarter.
How do you switch agencies step by step?
The order matters. Most of the damage in a switch happens when brands give notice first and sort out access later.
1. Make sure you own the account, before you give notice. A Klaviyo account has one Owner, and only the current Owner can make someone else the Owner. If your old agency set the account up, ask them to transfer ownership to you now, while the relationship is still friendly. Check the same for your SMS platform, your sending domain and DNS, your design files and any integrations.
2. Write down a baseline. Export the last few months of email and SMS revenue, revenue per recipient for each main flow, repeat purchase rate, time to second order, list growth and spam complaint rate, plus subscriber retention if you sell subscriptions. The new agency’s first quarter should be judged against records, not memory.
3. Get an outside audit. Ask the agencies you’re considering to audit the account before you choose. How each one reads the same account tells you more than any pitch deck, and the findings should be yours to keep. Our Klaviyo audit checklist shows what a good one covers.
4. Plan the handover. Agree the notice period, the last campaign the old agency sends, and who owns the calendar during the overlap. Ask for documentation: what each flow does, segment definitions and testing history.
5. Never pause live flows. This is the most common way brands lose revenue during a switch. Leave every flow running. The new agency builds replacements alongside them and switches over only when the new version performs at least as well.
6. Keep campaigns going. Gaps in your calendar cost revenue and can hurt engagement. Make sure someone owns every send during the transition.
7. Agree how success will be measured. Set the two or three numbers that should move in the first ninety days, and a checkpoint to review them.
8. Close the old agency’s access. Once the overlap ends, remove their users from Klaviyo and your other tools. Klaviyo won’t let you delete the Owner, which is one more reason step 1 comes first.
What should you ask the next agency about the takeover?
Choosing a partner is its own question. These are the ones specific to taking over a live account:
What will you change in the first thirty days, and what will you deliberately leave alone?
How do you test a rebuilt flow against the one it replaces before switching the old one off?
Who talks to our old agency during the handover, and who sends our campaigns in the overlap?
If we part ways one day, will everything you built still be in our account and our design files?
If you’re still deciding what kind of help comes next, see freelancer vs agency vs in-house. If you’ve decided on an agency, our shortlist of the best Klaviyo agencies for 7-figure brands can help.
What should you avoid during a switch?
Most failed switches come down to doing too much, too fast:
Switching right before your biggest sales period. If you must, keep the existing setup running through it. See our Black Friday playbook.
Letting the new agency rebuild everything at once.
Deleting old flows before replacements are proven.
Losing your testing history.
How Swayleo approaches this
This guide is written by Swayleo, a Klaviyo agency, so we’re biased. We’d still rather you switch well than switch to us badly. When we take over from another agency, we start with an audit and a baseline, keep every earning flow live, and rebuild in order of impact, testing new against old. Design usually changes early, because a consistent design system makes everything after it faster to build and measure. Some brands only switch the design side: we take design-only work as well as full service. Either way, the founders run the handover themselves, so nothing gets lost between a salesperson and a delivery team. See how we work.
Talk to Swayleo
Want the founders to look at this for your brand? If you’re a 7-figure Shopify or DTC brand, book a strategy call.
Shopify & DTC brands
Quick Answers
Frequently
Asked Questions
How do I know when to switch email marketing agencies?
Switch when results have stalled for several months without a clear explanation, reports show activity instead of outcomes, the work no longer fits your brand, or you’re managing the agency instead of it managing your program.
Will switching agencies hurt my email revenue?
It shouldn’t if you keep live flows running, write down a baseline and only replace flows once new versions perform at least as well.
What should I get from my old agency before leaving?
Ownership of your Klaviyo account, admin access to every other tool, all templates and design files in your ownership, documentation of flows and segments, and your testing history.
How long does an agency switch take?
It depends on your notice period and how much needs rebuilding, but plan for an overlap where someone clearly owns every send.
Should I switch agencies before Black Friday?
Avoid it if you can. If you must, keep your existing flows and setup running through the peak and make changes afterwards.
Shopify & DTC brands